JUDGMENT ANALYSIS: INDEPENDENT THOUGHT v. UOI

March 17, 2021, 5:43 p.m.   Dheerja  
Pens of Law students    


Profile of the Author: Aditi Dhamdhere of Modern Law College, Pune University.

INTRODUCTION

In the case, Independent Thought v. Union of India [i], the petitioner was Independent Thought, a registered society that has been working for the protection and advancement of child rights, and the respondents were the Union of India. Section 375 [ii] of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) delineates rape. A provision was added to the Section for the age of consensual sex as 18 years. Exception 2 [iii] to Section 375 stipulates that a husband can have sex without the consent of his wife who is in the age group of 15 to 18 years. The issue raised before the Supreme Court was to decide the constitutionality and legality of Exception 2 to Section 375 of IPC.

FACTS OF THE CASE [iv]

The petitioner is a society that has been working in the realm of child rights. It has been engaged in legitimate mediation, exploration, and preparation of issues concerning infringement of child rights. The society filed a writ petition under Article 32 [v] of the Constitution intending to bring forth the infringement of the rights of a girl child who gets married between the age of 15 to 18 years.

ISSUE BEFORE THE COURT

Whether sex between a man and his wife who is a girl child between 15 to 18 years of age amounts to rape?

ANALYSIS OF THE JUDGEMENT

The Division Bench of Justice Madan B Lokur & Justice Deepak Gupta while deciding the case opined the following:

Exception 2 of Section 375 IPC makes an irrational differentiation between a married girl child and an unmarried girl child with no justifiable reason or nexus. This superficial differentiation is opposed to principles laid down in Articles 14 [vi], 15(3) [vii] and Article 21 [viii] of the Constitution. No other provision in reformatory law confers any safeguard to the husband. It is inconsistent with the provisions of Sections 5 [ix] and 6 [x] of the POCSO Act, 2012. Non-consensual sex with the wife between the age of 15 to 18 years is a violation of human rights as stipulated under Section 2(d) [xi] of The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 and Section 3 [xii] of The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. Moreover, it infringes the right to bodily integrity and reproductive choices of the girl child. It has no stringent measures for the trafficking of the girl child. Hence, it is arbitrary, discriminatory and prejudicial to the welfare of the girl child.

A Woman is entitled to dignity, protection, and right to reproductive choices which ought to be regarded as given in the following cases: Suchita Srivastava v. Chandigarh Administration [xiii], State of Maharashtra v. Madhukar Narayan Mardikar [xiv], and Devika Biswas v. Union of India [xv].

Rape is a heinous crime that disregards the dignity of a girl, causes injury and defeats her opportunity of reproductive choices. It is a composite issue that needs careful consideration and deliberation as provided in the following cases: State of Karnataka v. Krishnappa [xvi], Bodhisattwa Gautam v. Subhra Chakraborty [xvii], and State of Punjab v. Gurmit Sigh [xviii].

The parliament has regularly updated the age of marriage and consent. Presently, a girl child is neither qualified for marriage nor can she give an assent before 18 years of age. So, when age has been increased in all the other laws then Exception 2 maintaining the age of assent for a wife who is 15 years of age is irrational, prejudicial, and violative of the rights of the girl child. It is arbitrary and discriminatory. Consequentially, it should be struck down as violative of part III of the Constitution. Exception 2 should delineate as follows to make it constant with the Constitution: “Sex or Sexual acts by a man with his wife not being 18 years, isn’t rape”. The issue under the consideration of the Court pertains only to marital rape of the girl child who is under 18 years of age and not above the age of 18 years. Therefore, the judgment did not remark whatsoever regarding the issue of marital rape of an adult woman.

This is a landmark case because the Union of India (Respondent’s) conflict was the custom that has been vigorously practiced for a while now in our country. Thus, the same should not be interfered with. The court didn’t concur with the argument asserting that since child marriages are common in different parts of India and have been followed as a convention over the years so they should be acknowledged as a way of life. It doesn’t imply that we have to accept it and ratify it by law. The legislation must be sufficiently rational to comprehend which custom is justifiable and which isn't.

Therefore, it was held that non-consensual sex with a girl child under the age of 18 years is rape irrespective of the status of marriage as it endangers a girl’s life both physically and emotionally.

CONCLUSION

Independent Thought case has made a significant impact in securing the rights of the girl child who are married before the age of 18 years and are forced to have sexual intercourse. The judgement did not deliberate on circumstances where the husband himself is minor and would be as innocent as the young girl. Further, the Court did not comment on the marital rape issue of an adult woman by emphasizing that marital rape isn’t the issue before the court. The reasoning the Court provided for Exception 2 that it is violative of Fundamental Rights is aligned to the argument for an adult woman whose dignity and bodily integrity are violated by non-consensual sex.

Disclaimer: This article is an original submission of the Author. Niti Manthan does not hold any liability arising out of this article. Kindly refer to our Terms of use or write to us in case of any concerns.


FAQ

Q1. Is it acceptable for a man to have non-consensual sex with a young girl just because she is married to him?

A1. No, it is not after the judgement of Independent Thought v. Union of India (2013).

References

[i] Independent Thought v. Union of India, WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. 382 OF 2013.

[ii] Section 375, KD GAUR, TEXTBOOK ON INDIAN PENAL CODE, 6TH EDITION, 2018, Pg.no.-880.

[iii] Exception 2 –Section 375, KD GAUR, TEXTBOOK ON INDIAN PENAL CODE, 6TH EDITION, 2018, Pg.no.-881.

[iv] Independent Thought v. Union of India, https://indiankanoon.org/doc/87705010/.

[v] Article 32 of the Constitution of India.

[vi] Article 14 of the Constitution of India.

[vii] Article 15(3) of the Constitution of India.

[viii] Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

[ix] Section 5 of the POCSO Act, 2012.

[x] Section 6 of the POCSO Act, 2012.

[xi] Section 2(d) of The Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.

[xii] Section 3 of The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
[xiii] Suchita Srivastava v. Chandigarh Administration, CIVIL APPEAL NO.5845 OF 2009.

[xiv] State of Maharashtra v. Madhukar Narayan Mardikar, AIR 1991 SC 207, (1991) 1 SCC 57.

[xv] Devika Biswas v. Union of India, (2016) 10 SCC 729.

[xvi] State of Karnataka v. Krishnappa, ILR 1994 KAR 89, 1993 (4) KarLJ 680.

[xvii] Bodhisattwa Gautam v. Subhra Chakraborty, 1996 AIR 922, 1996 SCC (1) 490.

[xviii] State of Punjab v. Gurmit Sigh, 1996 AIR 1393, 1996 SCC (2) 384.


Liked the article ?
Share this:

Tags

india ads fairnesscreams tv ads ban proposal anti ageing creams government 2006 micro small review big India Juvenile Justice rights Women justice Jurisdiction Constitution caa secularism amendment sedition Arbitration consumer complaint filing international laws wildlife protection animal laws USA china women empowerment pornography legal prostitution sex trafficking laws legalising Economy Measures RBI Coronavirus Reserve Bank of India stability coronavirus impact liquidity shantikanta das monetary policy repo rate moratorium disinformation fake news state of frenzy social media anger hate issue EpidemicDiseaseAct uniformcivilcode equality secular illegalimmigrants immigration assisteddying euthanasia police brutality custodial violence police efforts jail separation divorce hindu marriage family laws economic slowdown unemployment percapitaincome inflation GDP growth aggregate demand commercial surrogacy bill armed forces equal rights landmark judgement indian army transgender living conditions third gender Disability rights rape law Criminal law IPC Internship Program regulatory sandbox IRDA framework IRDA guidelines live environment RBI regulations pollution womeninmates punishment sexualassault wrongfulconvictions IPR EnvironmentLaws JudicialActivism Jurisprudence Internship singleparent adoption niti manthan prison reforms Niti manthan e-fradus cyber crimes It Laws Medico legal aid Media technology and democracy legal literacy Body Offences Housing infrastructure indian law global laws right to health fundamental right article 21 Indian penal code criminal law crimes against women rapecases IntellectualPropertyRights Trademark NuclearSecurity Cyberlaws judiciary petitions mercy petition review petition curative petition zero draft human rights business United nations ADR Law mediation negotiation conciliation Mahatama Gandhi economics technology technological unemployment network online consumption production working remotely law of sedition article 19 right to freedom and expression moblynching violence offence animalrights gayparenting pronouns fundamental duties Indian law Constitution of India covid19 criminal justice system constitutional administrative litigation Courts order commission report speedy trial Corrections legal aid legislature Police Successionlaw casestudy SARFAESI e-debate maritalrape 498A IPC Misuse nirbhaya rape case death penalty deterent theory covid-19 force majuere events Force Majeure Clauses coronavirus outbreak doctorine of frustration clauses contract UAPA 2019 Review indigenous people LabourLaws Familylaw dowry death white collar crimes plea bargaining menstruation myths defamation forgery events Results Phase 2 trespass mental health intellectual property rights Patent rights crimes lockdown child abuse traditional crime crime rate phishing ransomware cybercrime malware domestic violence doctoring lis pendens applicability conditions insensitive media coverage media Death News channel ayodhya judgement Group Discussion Exceprts naturaljustice legalprincipals Supremecourt crpc Bail Legalethics legal guidelines telemedicine legal issues Laws Section 269 Section 270 cholera privacy concern Divorce Muslim Women retention of property yemen conflict competition law enforcement 10 years administrativelaw PiracyLaw juvenile justice EIA Draft 2020 30th June 2020 Environmental Impact Assessment Climate Change Laws Dissent Research Group juvenile crimes Administration environment conservation Sustainable Oceans Énvironment Service laws Compassionate Appointments policy legislation webinar scientist climatologist report policy change TPA property patent law section 144 principles of natural justice justice delayed instant justice work from home InformationTechnology persons with disabilities discrimination health girls disease community duties individual contemporary world common interests duality MRTP Act Indian economy competition commission of india Competition Act appraisal singaporean court section 377 Navtej singh judgement IHL war crimes humanitarian law ipc beyond india extra territorial jurisdiction wife maintenance desertion marriage #digital strike #cyber security chinese apps #chinese apps #ad-hoc arbitration #institutional arbitration #environmental law #environment #human rights #strict liability Lok Adalats US-India Abortion laws Live-in-relationships Indian Judiciary Universal Healthcare Rules Based World Order. YL3 victim dying declaration wish last wish truth balanced cooperative bank sarfaesi act Internet Ban Censorship Website Ban #DPSP #state #covid #IP black money racism Skin colour Political system Unrest accountability Jammu and Kashmir Article 370 Abrogation Kidnapping and Abduction Indo-Nepal brutality dk basu guidelines Conflict Changing dynamics democracy international disputes prostitution in India extradition laws and treaties Surrogacy laws case study Law and Order society Legal Implications regulatory framework Betting Gambling Seventh Schedule Central Government Betting Laws Rights of a Man cyber delinquency Juvenile Justice Act Doctrine Part Performance Section 53-A CERC sustainable development Grid Code electricity laws electricity control Mental HealthCare Act WHO National Trust Act Disaster Mangement Indian legal Framework Female Criminality social structure Corporate Laws Corporate Veil Company Election Laws Electoral Reforms Law Commission of India Article 324 Election Commission contempt of court rule of law supreme court principle of natural justice judges criticism high court Fertility Assisted Reproductive Technology Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Bill Legal Evolution Literature growth goods and services Predatory Pricing Market legal remedies cryptocurrency virtual currency santhanam committee ethical behavior border military LAC Aksai Chin revenge porn FIR SC/ ST Reservation artificialintelligence Privacy privacy specialmarriageact constitutional constitutionality Article 139A Education National Education Policy HRDMinistry feminism Gender Inequality Sex god juristic personality PIL earth nature ecosystem public trust Section 420 ASCI Advertisements Covid-19 Online Dispute Resolution dispute JusticeOnTime Cyber Space Security election Cloning Senior citizens Human Rights arrest CrPC procedural laws curative legislation Ration card Judicial Review Writ Jurisdiction Internet Covid19 indian passport foreigners-act extradition law laws in India Inheritance Laws Section 6 Domicile CLAT NLU belgium extradition treaty vicarious liability law of torts common law International Commercial Arbitration Private Defence Legal Right energy consumption national solar mission international law economic sanction tax structure Reforms NDPS Act Section64A genocide research projects internships summer school Virtual Courts Digital India NDHM Press Regulation italian-marines fishermen kerala international waters arbitration womenrights witchhunting janaushadischeme healthcare laws medical national health policy healthcare national digital health mission world health organisation legal jurisprudente draft health data management 2020 concerns drawbacks ministry of health and family affair sting operations media trial press rights right to privacy Twitter Prashant Bhushan period leave probate essentials for will will Technical biometrics Laws for women settlement mandalcommission 30 years gandhi principles Indianlegalsystem nitimanthan CELRA Climate Change Phase 3 sakshiaggarwal communication skills youcanskilldevelopment client counselling soumikghoshal sbi protest farm acts agriculture farmers anti-farmers men Executive power constitutional law Article 73 finance transparency political parties bonds Sexual Harassment Ministry of Human Resource Development Educational Reforms sabarimala case untouchability cruelty misuse by women gender biased 488A ban of apps section 69A tiktok app compensation section 357A state s bankruptcy Insolvency_law_committee ibc insolvency_bankruptcy_act insolvency nclt students accessibility internet #righttoeducation nuclear weapon treaty legality advisory opinion international restorative justice punishment theory copyright law distance education virtual teaching Fundamental Rights Rape SC/ST Forest Rights Act Forest Conservation bitcoin vaccination ibc suspension financial creditors ministry of corporate affairs substantial acquisition takeover public announcement control out of court settlement history banking law sebi stressed assets banking regulation dispute resolution professionalism private sector fund sourcing banks publication copyright infringement publishing house penguin environmental jurisprudence 2020 indian legal system acquisition section 62 convertible investees companies act ABUSE ONLINE IPC CRIME WOMEN INDIA ONLINE ABUSE WOMEN CRIME CRIMINAL LAW registrations open competition sushruta apply extempore centre for medical and health law ethic studies sex workers religion extra-territorial technological advancement cerestrial environment_protection infrastructure goa doctrineofpleasure crown Arrest code of civil procedure offender access to justice concilation remedy presidentialelections developing nations tiktok universal health coverage comedians freedom of speech and expression OTT Platforms Content Regulation Section 375 forced marriages Precautionary measures Guidelines covid crisis women assault section 353 cops andhra pradesh chief minister dream 11 economic impact online gambling salary income tax rti spam troll misinformation methods civil law section 118 kerala police act section 66a animal rights slaughter customs act CAROTAR FTA TARRIF rules of origin hardship of importer rights of animals need for amendement meagre punishment legitimacy constitutionalism liability right to healthy environment degrading environment social responsibility restructuring mergers amalgamation turkey challenge accepted outrage unity child rights rte right to education non-access conclusive proof marital relationships matrimony arbitral award thorium atomic energy act nuclear energy nuclear power atomic energy swadhar home widows vrindavan infringement comparative advertisement trademarks act income tax act non resident indians FEMA MONARCHY SIKKIM namgyal dynasty partner state ONUS guilty Burden of proof legal burden parties self defense legal right prostitutes Winter school International Criminal Law Ministry of Finance Welfare Digital Budget Finance Budget 2021 Democracy Coups Myanmar Voter Fraud Corruption corrupt governments voter fraud unrecognized ineffective Dictators projects development jungle capital assets funds partership water riparian basin collaboration advocate amit mazumdar soft skills advocacy terrorism massacres gun ICC ivorycoast LaurentGbagbo Space Policy Treaties Space Outer space Foreign award public policy ZERO FIR LAW hindu law INDIA PROPERTY RIGHTS DAUGHTER WOMEN RIGHTS AMENDEMENTS HINDU SUCCCESSION distributed ledger technology block chains digital age Exception 2 Habeas Corpus Case Basic Structure Doctrine Adults Care and Protection Juvenile delinquency Medical Negligence Due Care Criminal Liability Civil Liability Stockholm Conference Uniform Civil Code Personal Laws hindu wife live in relationships mental disorder mental health care act advance directive bail sentence CEDAW NCRB Sexual abuse International Bill of Rights POCSO Act Comparative analysis Ted Talk Renewable Energy Trend Energy Projection advaadvance directiv,psychiatry Schedule VII of CA 2013 Amendment 2019 Companies Act 2013 CSR